Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Sorry, this I'm completely wron... I mean: I was testing if you read the comments before upvoting.

The 1/2mv^2 vs mv points to an exhaust speed as low as possible, to get as much momentum as possible from as little energy expenditure as possible.

Now, if your exhaust comes from the outside world then that makes perfect sense. And this is why you have turboprop and turbofan engines: you slow down the exhaust of the turbine, speed up outside air, and do a favorable energy/momentum trade.

But in space you have to carry the mass you will exhaust. You don't have much choice: all the energy you get from burning fuel will be transfer to kinetic energy of your exhaust (in the reference frame of the rocket).




Yeah, you're right. A bit of algebra reveals that your delta-V per MASS of fuel (which is a frame-independent quantity) goes as the (propellant specific chemical energy)^.5.

However, it is also true that if you calculate the delta-V per unit propellant ENERGY used, it decreases with the propellant specific energy.

Since you don't really care about how much energy you carry but only about how much fuel you need to use per delta-V, it's always better to have higher exhaust energy. (As long as you are using a chemical propellant, i.e. the mass carrying the energy and the reaction mass are the same.)

The statement in the article about "propulsive efficiency" is total bogus. First: the relative kinetic energy of the rocket and the exhaust IS a frame-dependent quantity, so it's meaningless. Second, any reasonable measure of efficiency, like the delta-V per fuel energy, reveals that the "optimal" value is an exhaust velocity of zero. (Optimal in the sense that it's more energy efficient, but only because the delta-V goes to zero slower than the energy. It's still a useless optimum, because it results in no delta-V at all...)




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: