Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Agree entirely. They don't launch products with the hope of having a long term product. They launch products to experiment and learn more about ad delivery. The core ad system is the main priority. As such, falling in love with any product that isnt their ad tech means understanding the product may disappear for no decent reason.



I would take it a step further and say that they don't launch products; they launch experiments. It's a giant Mechanical Turk setup.


And people happily store their 20 years of photo memories there...one day it will not be a custom inbox view or a voicemail transcript that will disappear.


I am not sure if you are using the term "Mechanical Turk" correctly. Would you mind clarifying?


They're likely referring to Amazon Mechanical Turk:

https://www.mturk.com

as opposed to the chess-playing variety:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Turk


Got it, MTurk defintely makes more sense than the Turk :)

Which actually raises an interesting point. The word data comes from Latin dare for "to give". So, as Rob Kitchin observes, while something like MTurk can be properly described as collecting "data", Google and the vast majority of networked platforms should really be more properly described as collecting "capta", from Latin capere, or "to take".


You are absolutely correct and I completely agree; this is part of what I wanted to get at. Google also uses this two-fold "data-gathering disguised as a service" methodology in its captchas -- as your reference to "capare" reminded me. :)


It's actually interesting because Rob Kitchin has started almost exclusively using the word "capta" in his later works. I'm tempted to follow him in doing that in my personal writings. (Captcha and other forms of "data labor" [1] or even "data slavery" is also something that I've started exploring.)

[1] https://uknowledge.uky.edu/geography_facpub/11/


I had no idea anyone was doing in-depth research into this kind of -- as he aptly calls it -- data labor. This would really merit its own HN submission. Thank you for showing me!


Becoming 'a worker' is very eye opening experience.


Point being we, the users, are the mechanical turks, carrying out Google's experiments.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: