Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Is there any reason now why Google shouldn't shutdown all their EU web services and remove its divisions like it did in China?

If they did so they can conveniently also ignore that $5B anti-trust fine.




And drop out of the EU market? That sounds insane.


I could be wrong but wouldn't the global versions still be accessible and capable of selling ads?


If you accept visitors from the EU, you have to abide by their laws. If you're exclusively based outside of the EU, you could just ignore the laws. But Google has offices inside the EU, so they can't.


Google benefits from this and almost certainly secretly lobbied for it.

This is great for the FAANG providers who already have automated content control tools and massive help centres to act on anything 24/7. It is a death-knell to any upstart startup who would challenge Youtube or Facebook however.


A lot of money. More than they'd lose by complying, probably.


Wouldn't they still get cash from advertisers? The sites are still accessible from the EU, it just means local businesses who want to advertise need to pay the US division?


As a general rule, in most jurisdictions, you cannot do business across international borders in this way, no. As soon as someone from the EU pays Google while they are physically inside of the EU, that business is subject to the EU's laws.


So if I start an online service in the US and someone in the EU buys I'm liable to EU laws and fines?


If someone in the EU buys it while they are in the EU, you just imported something to the EU and the EU's laws apply to you, yes. If that person buys it from you in the US and then carries it back to the EU, they have the liability for following law, paying duties and taxes, etc. When it comes to things that are completely digital, I believe where the money is changing hands is what matters most.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: