Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

.NET Core took a lot of ideas from the node platform. Have you tried this?



We have, I haven’t personally done any of it in production because I didn’t really see a reason to use it over node. My coworkers did a few pocs though, and initially had to spend a lot of time actually getting it to work with deployment. I have no idea why that was, you’d expect it to just work considering it’s a complete Microsoft setup, but it didn’t work out.

So it was a terribly expensive poc, because our most expensive resource is the time developers/operations spend. I mean, core is more performant than node technically, but as far as cost-efficiency goes, time to market is just much more important than technical performance in our organization. We have a lot of iron, and we don’t have a lot of users. We’re a muniplacity of average size after all, the most simultaneous visitors we’ve ever had across every system we operate is in the tens of thousands.

As far as development goes, I don’t think there is much difference between core and standard, but I’ll admit that I haven’t looked into it since 1.0.

We’re in this weird spot where we’re using more and more powershell and azure orchestration for back-end services that used to be powered by C#. A lot of that has also moved from development to operations, so that development is mainly focused on building APIs, working with data-sets or building various minor web/mobile apps, and Node + JS is just working out better than everything else.

We’ve tried core, we’ve tried Django and flask, we’ve tried a bunch of other stuff, but for getting an app up and running the same hour you start building it? Well, node just works for us.

I’m not saying node or JS are better than .Net though, I don’t think it is and I’d still prefer Java or C# if I was building something major.


I stayed away from Core because of the issues you mention, but it's gotten a lot better recently.

Did a POC for an API that wouldn't break anything if it had to be reworked, and it was a breeze.

Of course, if Node works for you, then it does :) but my recent experience is that Core has gotten better and merits consideration.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: