Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Personally, I think we'd all be a lot better off if we adopted open and polyamorous relationships in a large way.

Unfortunately, jealously is wired deep into our lizard brains by evolution because it has enormous survival value for both sexes, though for different reasons. Men wan women to be monogamous so that they bear only their children, and women want men to be monogamous so that they support only their children.

[Addendum, since this comment seems to be getting a lot of attention]: When I was in college I had a long-distance relationship. Because we were 2000 miles apart it seemed silly to maintain exclusivity. People have needs. But when I found out one day that my girlfriend was out with another man I found myself overcome with jealousy. The intensity of the feeling took me completely by surprise. I was literally paralyzed by it for several hours, as in I sat in the hallway of my dorm room and could not move. This is not something I chose for myself. The intellectual part of me realizes that everyone would be better off if we didn't feel jealousy. But we do. It's not something we can simply choose to put aside.




> Unfortunately, jealously is wired deep into our lizard brains

Not actually the case, given what we know of the incredible variety of sexual/reproductive practices in pre-modern societies.

Its unfortunate that we make the mistake of observing current cultural behaviour and transhistoricising it onto all previous societies, presuming that their social relations must have been just the same as ours. EvoPsych in particular seems to be littered with this kind of fallacy.


> Not actually the case, given what we know of the incredible variety of sexual/reproductive practices in pre-modern societies.

Reference?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: