Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Between CopperheadOS and CyanogenMod imploding, what's left? LineageOS and Replicant? Anything else?



LineageOS seems to be alive and well.

I'm currently using it while I wait for the Librem5, after which I hope to say goodbye to the dumster fire that is Android.


So what do you plan to move to? iOS?


The Librem 5 runs on a Debian (iirc) based Linux distribution with a custom phone-focused userland, running everything through Matrix


Not only does it run PureOS (Debian derivative) but it's not restricted to run only PureOS. I could run Arch Linux on my phone, yay!


If Microsoft, who seem to be on an open source binge, would let loose WindowsPhone 8.1 ...

(It's not like MS are doing anything in that space anymore, except piling up Win10 stuttering on the remains ... and it might, perhaps, possibly, stub someone's toe ...)

If anyone has grafted a Metro Design scion on a Linux rootstock, that would be worth a look too.


But what about apps? That's a major part of the reasons why Windows Phone died, developers refused to commit resources to port/develop apps to yet another mobile platform.

IIRC, Palm webOS tried to fix that by allowing developers use familiar HTML/JS-based tooling (Enyo) [0] to build apps for that platform, but the die had been cast with iOS and Android.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enyo_(software)


Yep, that's the unfortunate rub. And why I'm on iOS now ("dumpster fire" is also my take on the alternative ...)


I will never use a Microsoft device.


I still have an old phone on which I'd installed CyanogenMod. Unfortunately, it's old enough that LineageOS isn't an option, the only updates were nightlies, and it never got past KitKat. About the only use case I can find for it now is as a SIP handset for my Asterisk box. I might just chuck it into a recycling bin, since it's a 3G handset to begin with.

There's an unofficial LineageOS build for my daily driver, but that, too, is trouble waiting to happen since VoLTE isn't supported, and I visit Michigan often enough to need it; I'm on T-Mobile, and a lot of their rural Michigan coverage is Band 12 LTE-only.


There is also https://postmarketos.org/ for the adventurous :)


Tried it on a N900. i3wm with its hardware keyboard works very well!


Sailfish OS [1]

And an alternative for WearOS is AsteroidOS.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sailfish_OS


There's eelo, a recently crowdfunded new project. They build on top of LineageOS.

Unfortunately their goals seem not to align with their actions:

They claim to focus on privacy, yet the first thing they publish is a new launcher.

Also they plan to offer a lot of cloud replacements. What do they replace it with? Their own cloud offering. I'd rather host this stuff myself.

But maybe I'm just not their target audience...


I didn't hear about CyanogenMod imploding. What happened there?


Cyanogen Inc, the company founded to do commercial work on it and running a lot of the project infrastructure, ran out of money after some weird things like cancelling a licensing deal with OnePlus suddenly and closed. community part of the project rebranded to LineageOS


Right. The community part - which is still alive and well in its rebranded form as LineageOS - was doing the most important work anyway (or, even if that's a loaded statement, the community part was extremely productive and still is).


> after some weird things like cancelling a licensing deal with OnePlus suddenly

just to be specific, they licensed the exclusive right to the cyanogen name in india to micromax (while previously licensing the non-exclusive right to oneplus in all regions), who then got an injunction against oneplus selling their devices in india.


Factory images improved and then surpassed Cyanogenmod in a whole bunch of ways.


Still no universal way to revoke fine grained permissions from apps in factory Android.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: