Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> It's a bad analogy but it's as though car repair shops were illegal and you could only repair your own car.

It's a great analogy: just look at the Mac repair shops being sued by Apple, or the idiotic things printer manufacturers and even coffee pod makers do to prevent people from "pirating" their machines.

Free software, and arguably free markets, mean free secondary markets for used goods. That includes all the repair shops and a cottage industry of craftsmen who provide those goods and services.




Free secondary markets is a great analogy for open source. What comes to mind is forks and plugins of open source projects, I guess they are a secondary market for the main project.


Full forks are very rare. I could count important ones on my fingers.

GNOME forks Cinnamon and Mate (active), libav vs ffmpeg (now closing), mplayer/2/mpv (mostly overtaken by last one).

Most common pattern is multiple packages solving the same problem, rather than forks - and incompatible versions.


LibreOffice? MariaDB? Ubuntu?


I would not call Ubuntu a Fork...

The rest are good examples but of the millions of projects very very few are forked successfully

I could add a couple to this list as well but that does not change the fact that successful forks are exceeding rare


MariaDB and LibreOffice were forked for license reasons - the fork was not avoidable. They also took over original code development.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: