Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

There's no way that's true unless you live in a really messed up market, taxation-wise.

Here in the SF bay area I have gigabit internet through comcast and allow them to shove their "basic" cable TV service in my general direction (it's not even hooked up) because it 'saves' me $5 or $10 or whatever per month on my internet charges. (All I know is the total bill is $144 which is less than the advertised rate of $169 for Gigabit, but I've been through this excercise many times in the past 5 years, where I try to get JUST internet, and they offer me tv+internet for $5 or $10/mo cheaper; last time I didn't even ask for the full numbers)

Fees:

Broadcast TV Fee $8

FCC Regulatory Fee: $0.08

Franchise Fee: $2.01

PEG Access Support: $0.55

Local Utility User Tax: $1.55

State Sales Tax: $0.23

So, $12.42 in taxes and fees, only $8 of which is clearly related to broadcast TV (and here I'm assuming I don't pay that fee just by being a subscriber to a cable company, even if I get internet-only).

I plan on calling sometime soon to clarify, but I've done it many times, and it never saves me a penny.




Somewhat unrelated, just reduced my internet speed from gigabit to 250Mbps; upload down from 35Mbps to 10Mbps and it's $96.95 'before taxes' .. hopefully, at least, I won't have that $8 broadcast fee, but I'm pretty mixed about this whole thing. I only got gigabit because I could, but I might miss that upload, just a little bit. And it's only $40 per month that I'm saving. Maybe $45 tops. Still, interested to see how it pans out. And finally I get to return the damn cable box they won't let me return as long as I have TV service. And -1 subscriber count, almost worth it for me just for that alone. They tried to throw a 2 year $99 gigabit offer at me, but I keep hoping SOME day I'll get FTTH.. I know, don't hold your breath.


There is also the $10 "HD Technology Fee". If you have multiple TVs it's $10 for each additional set top box per month. I know our 6 TVs is a little extreme but that by itself would be an extra $50 a month.


Ah. I have no idea what kind of box they gave us, it just sits in the attic. I've got 3 TVs; 1x 4k and 2x 1080p but they're all hanging off the TiVo Bolt and TiVo Minis.

We're definitely not getting charged an extra tenner for an HD box.


I looked at my bill. I pay $140 per month for cable and internet. Actual bill is $181. So more like 30%.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: