Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> You are excited that google is going to continue to monitor and spy on their users?

No of course not. I'd rather they didn't spy on anyone.

> Why should everyone adhere to your "wellbeing"?

I don't want everyone to adhere to my definition of wellbeing. I am simply happy that Google are developing tools that I believe will help me personally. This has nothing to do with my expectations for everyone else.

> Are you incapable of just going to sleep? Do you really need a cronjob to shutdown your laptop?

Yes.

> Why do you assume that your lack of self control projects to everyone else?

I don't.

> Instead of looking to google or tech companies, why don't you develop self-control? Do you leave your TV on and then complain that broadcasters aren't coming to your home and turning it off for you?

Believe me I've tried. I meditate, I see a therapist, I get help from my social group, I have hobbies and relationships to occupy me. That doesn't mean I am not also addicted technology.

> People like you scare me because you have a tyrannical mindset. The "everyone must be like me or they should all be forced to be like me" mindset.

This is such a bizarre conclusion to me. Firstly, I don't really care what Google provide for anyone but me. I think this is exciting because I think I will find it useful. I haven't said anything about how I think it will cure societies ills or anything regarding how it will affect anyone but myself. Secondly, you realise that up until now Google's algorithms are tuned very specifically to increase the time you spend using their products. They use all kinds of psychological tricks to bypass your normal self control. The best thing Google could do for me is to stop using these tricks but unfortunately, that would probably cost them a lot of money. Instead, here they are providing help for people like me who need it while not changing the experience of their services for the rest. I don't see why it's tyrannical to want the services I choose to use to have the features I want in them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: