Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> and a person not overly taken with his “charisma” wonders if his interest in mass transit is in scuttling it.

No, you’re just a run-of-the-mill conspiracist, and cynic.

To note, he actually hasn’t thrown in with hyperloop, he open sourced he idea for people to iterate. He literally just thinks he can build a cheaper tunnel, and I haven’t seen any serious proposals to run hyperloops through them.




>No, you’re just a run-of-the-mill conspiracist, and cynic.

May be those are not really bad. We are living in a time where stuff that conspiracist, and cynics have been saying for years turning out to be true...

Also, while you accuse them, are you sure you are just not being a true believer of the cult of Elon Musk


> No, you’re just a run-of-the-mill conspiracist, and cynic.

In a time where just being skeptical of Musk gets you attacked, I am not sure you have the authority to say anybody else is run-of-the-mill. He may be a cynic, but the mainstream sentiment towards Musk is almost church-like, so generally people outside of that are not in the majority.

Look, I get it, nobody else seems to be doing exciting tech lately and Musk is certainly not doing CRUD apps, so I see where the excitement is coming from, but I also see a lot of fanaticism and PR bullshit around Musk, so I'd say some amount of skepticism is well placed.


Read Bloomberg, WSJ, Fox, heck NYT, Washington Post for articles critical of him or his ventures. He got a lot of PR for sure, but he's hardly worshiped in the mainstream.

> Look, I get it, nobody else seems to be doing exciting tech lately and Musk is certainly not doing CRUD apps, so I see where the excitement is coming from, but I also see a lot of fanaticism and PR bullshit around Musk, so I'd say some amount of skepticism is well placed.

Skepticism is always healthy, but dropping false facts like this is not: "He making his money on cars with lithium batteries, and chemical rockets. That’s where he’s spending and making his billions. He’s dropping 3.8% of his recent $2.6 billion award on this project"

Also, aren't we getting infinite streams of what Google, Amazon, FB, Apple, Microsoft are up to? Count how many articles on HN about Tesla vs. Google?


Have you come across the idea that "All advertising is good advertising".

Even people blaming/skeptical or even hating on Elon Musk is doing good PR for Musk and his companies.

What something like Musk cannot afford is indifference from people. So the important task for something like Musk is to get people talk about them. It does not really matter if it good or bad.


> We are living in a time where stuff that conspiracist, and cynics have been saying for years turning out to be true..

We also live in a time where stuff that conspiracists and cynics have been saying for years is absolute bullshit. Don't fall victim to confirmation bias.


>We also live in a time where stuff that conspiracists and cynics have been saying for years is absolute bullshit.

We are also living in a time where things like ubeam and Theranos can get millions in funding..and various nefraious schems that intend to take the naive public for a ride...

May be, don't fall for that..




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: