Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> lifting weight is very artificial.

Please explain

Have you tried group classes?

A lot of the activity that you mentioned can be done in a gym but at the same time I would like to say there is no match to being outdoor. Short on time then hit a gym otherwise outdoors are worth it.

Weight lifting also makes you stronger and less prone to injuries.




One thing to make clear here (which I think you intend but don’t make explicit) is the difference between free weights and machines. Lifting free weights engages large groups of muscles and their coordination in balance and stabilization through the movements, which contributes greatly to injury prevention. Machines tend to isolate muscles and provide stabilization and restriction, so you don’t get these benefits.


Agree. Working out with machines is similar to sitting on a chair :-). For newbies, machines are great to improve their form


> "For newbies, machines are great to improve their form"

Well, there we do disagree ;) The activation patterns which are crucial to balance and stabilization don't get developed when using machines, and you can build up muscles much more quickly than connective tissue (tendons and ligaments). It's all too easy to into a situation where you're strong enough to lift weight that you can't stabilize under stress, and that's when injury is likely to occur. Weak tendons and ligaments coupled with poor stabilization activation patterns is a recipe for injuries. Better to start off with lighter free weight and good form for long term health and strength.

I don't have it at hand, but I recall a trainer encouraging a progression that went along the lines of "Form, then Speed, then Weight". If this jogs anyone's memory and has a reference (perhaps with a correction or expansion), I'd appreciate it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: