Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

And replace it with what exactly? Physical devices - Yubikey - are a neat idea, but not everything supports them. Biometrics is not password, that's a username replacement.

Also, it doesn't matter. Passwords, secret hashes, ssh keys; anything can be accidentally acquired.




> Yubikey - are a neat idea, but not everything supports them.

It's a fair point, but in general security has no silver bullets. Build a better lock, and attackers will build a better lockpick (or go through a window instead).

Lack of universal U2F support (a broader login security spec that Yubikeys supports) is Yubikey's weakness, but it only helps the attackers to be a security nihilist.

More and more sites are starting to support U2F. The biggest being Google (which covers Gmail, Google Cloud, Google Docs, etc), but also Github, Facebook, and Dropbox also support it, among others.

The trade-off between usability and security applies here - prior to meltdown/spectre, authentication cookies were happily isolated, so logging in once every 30-days seemed reasonable. Now, cycling login cookies every day or so is a more aggressive policy that is arguably better, but unfortunately, automatically logging users out after a short period hurts site adoption.


To be fair, maybe around half of all websites with login and password don't seem to require them at all and only seem to have accounts in order to obtain a valid email address for marketing.


Can you give an example?


HN for all the people who read and don't comment comes to mind.


Not replacing them, but MFA and good identity management is a start.


Exactly, fingerprints (and more generally biometrics) are usernames, not passwords.


Fingerprints are not passwords or usernames. They're another form of authentication.

Remember: MFA is a two-or-more combination of: something you know (password, pin, etc.), something you have (keycard, token, fob, etc.), something you are (fingerprint, iris scan, voice recognition, etc.), and potentially even somewhere you are (geolocation).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: