Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

They should have thought this one through a bit better. A fair number of people will take a refusal to strengthen the system as proof that the system is already being tampered with. That may or may not be the case but the head of the election committee should be happy that outsiders are showing the flaws, not arrest them. After all everybody benefits from a solid system, right?

This is also going to draw a lot of international scrutiny.




Actually, I hope this one draws a lot of international scrutiny.

Unfortunately, the way things work in India, there's way too much bureaucracy with these sort of things and a bunch of old people running the show who are very much resistant to change (not to mention the potential $$$). Unless the matter is really played up by the media (which in itself is another animal to be wary of), this would have gone through without a question. With the public outcry and the coverage of this arrest, there might be Public Litigations coming in which can atleast halt the process and get due diligence.


Shooting the messenger is still wildly popular in plenty of places.

Does India have whistleblower protection written in to law?

(that would not help Hari directly but it could help him in his defense to not reveal his source)


Now I'm not too familiar with the Indian Penal Code and Law in general, but there have been instances of whistleblowers being silenced in the past one way or another if the spotlight or public movement momentum is slow to follow. The chances of this happening are more in certain parts of the country like Bihar and UP etc.

It's unfortunate but the situation is slowly improving as time goes by and connectivity and access of information improves.


Incidentally, the whistleblower protection bill was passed barely a week ago: http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article560731.ece

The place to lodge all such complaints is http://cvc.nic.in/lodgecomp.htm

I would'nt be surprised if this law was invoked during the legal defense.


India is a model democracy with transparent election process.

India is litigation prone, and courts take decades to deliver justice.

Everyone who has lost a election in the last 20 years is going to claim election was rigged.

the few bad things we have inherited in, Parliament and legislative assemblies can be not allowed to function by a small group of irritant elected representatives.

hope sanity prevails with civil servants and he get released soon, and we have a open debate at various levels


Now why on earth would that get voted down?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: