Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Go is an open language

From what I've seen, this holds only as long as you keep the proposals minimal and restricted to aforesaid hacking around the limitations built into the language. I'm happy to be shown evidence to the contrary: have there ever been any proposals, reacted to in a not-completely-negative way, that were like "uh, maybe we didn't have the right idea about <something basic>, let's do this instead"?

I'll argue there won't be. Every community has a culture: Go's is delightfully warm, friendly, and inclusive, but also surprisingly distrustful of learning that there are easy-to-understand but powerful language features they could be using to write maintainable code without "getting a PhD in type theory from the nearest university" (to strawman a certain [type of] person [I've often encountered when arguing about these things]).

Go has done many things right (aside from the community, good concurrency and really fast compiles come to mind) but language design is not one of them.




Go has done nothing new for fast compile times, like any old timer coder will remember from Algol linage of compilers, with Turbo Pascal for MS-DOS being a good example of how long ago those fast compile times are known.


I'm sadly too young and ignorant of CS/technology history to be well-acquainted with the "old times". (It's something I intend to fix.)

Even so, I'm all for praising the good things that Go does: if nothing, because of the tremendous mindshare it's getting and the number of people it reaches.


Codegear has kept some of the Turbo Pascal stuff on their museum site.

For example, Turbo Pascal 5.5 targeting MS-DOS was released in 1989 and was compiling 34,000 lines/minute.

https://edn.embarcadero.com/article/20803

This is just one example, there are plenty of other languages to choose from with a module based compilation model, only C and C++ toolchains have lousy build times given their textual inclusion model.

http://www.drdobbs.com/cpp/c-compilation-speed/228701711

So the only achievement of Go's compilation speed was making younger generations think it is something extraordinary.


Not to mention that there are modern languages with fast compilers too. D is an example.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: