Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> I know they do. I just don't see what that gets me if I already know their email address.

They most likely use another email address for their anonymous internet account but even if they do, they're likely to be logged in in their main google account at the same time (since you can be logged in in multiple email accounts).

So, in this case, reddit (or whatever popular website) admins would be able to gather more information than what they should be able to get. It's a loss of privacy for the person concerned..

Beside this, it could be used for phishing to make sure only your target is the one getting the phishing page.

Or, you could combine it with geoip to get the zip code of the person logging in, a lookup of the different names of people living in that zip code (through the yellow pages or equivalent) and just check all of the first name last name combinations @gmail.com. At the speed of 1000 possible email addresses every 25 seconds, you could probably guess the email of quite a few visitors I think.




>At the speed of 1000 possible email addresses every 25 seconds, you could probably guess the email of quite a few visitors I think.

No way! Do you know how many Google accounts are out there? As I mentioned before, the person would have to, at the rate given, stay on the site for 2 hours to even have a statistical chance of being guessed unless you knew exactly who the target was.

Overall, this issue seems to only concern a specific individual that's being targeted by another specific entity. It doesn't seem useful or workable at all if you're guessing against a set of known emails.


> No way! Do you know how many Google accounts are out there?

Doesn't matter, I don't care about them. I just care if the person reading right now has initials SB, SM or KAC and might be in a position to say "Sir, have you seen this article?" (note: I have no idea who in the Trump administration might be using non-archived private email or whether rhesus nut or them are actually using Gmail, initials were chosen for names I know are still in their positions at the time I'm writing this)




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: