Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Push notifications and home-screen icons are strictly opt-in. If you don't want them, don't opt, simple as. I use webapps for several things because I can much better protect myself from tracking and data-harvesting with a well-configured browser than I can using a native app.



As I said, desktop Safari allows websites to prompt me for push notifications.

I can't stand it: that a web site has the ability to display a modal prompt sheet that I have to cancel.


There's a preference to disable this, though. Don't get me wrong - it's awful and I hate it. But I'm sure there are valid use-cases for people who use e.g. webmail.


This isn't new. Desktop browsers have been showing modal prompts via the javascript `prompt()` method for quite some time.


> This isn't new.

Just because it is old doesn't make it a good user experience.


It's not coincidental that the ability to do so has been actively limited by so many browsers (with opt-out forever options in some cases).


It's not modal (like `alert`), it doesn't steal focus, at least not on any browser I've used.


Disable it.

It's a feature some people like and use. I like getting notifications from some services I use without needing to keep a browser window open on that page to get notified. And I like not having to download and install yet another flipping app to get that feature.


I cant imagine a service that you frequent enough to want push notifications but not enough that you would be willing to install a native app for a smoother experience.


Installing an app is not a smoother experience. Allowing notifications is one click. Also, apps don't always have the same features as websites. You also make the assumption that services I use with browser notifications also have apps. This is not true in the slightest. And in some cases, I still prefer the website over an app.

How is it hard to imagine a service I don't frequent use but when I do, I want notifications? I use these services a few times a year at most. Why would I want to install an app if they have it?


One where the developer does not have enough resources to develop for and support multiple platforms?


Right, but the parent's argument is that web notifications are a way to avoid installing a native app.


My argument is not limited to some thin line you define. Please don't speak for me or put words in my mouth that are not true.


You get it.


> I cant imagine a service that you frequent enough to want push notifications but not enough that you would be willing to install a native app for a smoother experience.

Um. Email?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: