Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Shelling Seoul is worse.

Just ask yourself which would be worse for you, say, a week or even a month without power or a rain of explosives randomly demolishing buildings in your city.

We can get stuff working one way or the other without networked computers but there is no reasoning with shells.




There's been a lot of civilian casualties in Syria where large cities like Aleppo have been bombed to hell and back, but millions of people made it out of there alive.

It's not a great situation to be in, but many were able to flee to better places. If the entire grid is down there are no better places.


Shelling affects one city, whereas destroying the power grid can affect a whole country.


Shelling a major metropolitan area will kill thousands of people within hours. The power grid going down doesn't typically kill very many people unless it is down for a long time.


It won't be MY city they are shelling, they cannot reach my city with their guns. Even if they could we are low down on the list of targets. However they can reach my city in a broad bring down all water systems attack. I suspect there are only a couple vendors of water control systems so if there is a hold in one vendor's water control system they will attack everyone at once. Tiny towns with < 500 people will be hit, and I don't know if my town is one or not. (actually tiny towns are probably easier to target, large cities probably have a mix of systems so they are more likely to get by with a general everyone conserve water message, whiel the small towns are down completely.


Many municipalities have sold off large chunks of their infrastructure to private companies that are always more concermed with profit than expenses like "security".

It stands to reason that the smaller towns will be hit the hardest since they're the least prepared for electronic warfare. Their IT department is going to be the same guy that tests the water and removes dead animals from the reservoir.


Hospital generators will run dry within days, and then you'll be losing thousands of people who are dependent on life-support equipment, medication that needs refrigeration, or those that are in urgent need of surgery.

You have about 48 hours until things start to get really ugly. See also: Hurricane Katrina. They were able to minimize casualties by moving people to other hospitals that had power. Imagine if there weren't any.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: