Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Because implementing an Idea is most of the time harder than having an Idea

And becausing aquiring the knowledge to implement the Idea is also a lot harder than the effort needed to aquire an Idea

Finally, I think because people who do and know how to do are so preocupied with the tuff-ness of implementing the Idea they sometimes loose enthusiam and in many way this sometimes ties them down or set them back a little, and it the worry free business student just irritates them




"Because implementing an Idea is most of the time harder than having an Idea"

I think the difficulty is not in the hacking skills, though. Therefore it seems to me the arrogance of hackers is unwarranted. While I have a science degree, I taught myself programming with a couple of books - it really is not a secret superpower that should make the rest of mankind bow down before me. It is a skill like any other.

Personally, I would be delighted to meet a business person who is dedicated to making an idea a reality.

There might be an issue of trust: typically, business people are perceived as the people who screw things up and make life bad for the programmers. Therefore, just bumping into a random business person, a hackers enthusiasm might be limited.

Another thing that sucks about hacker arrogance: most hackers really only want to work on their own ideas. That makes finding co-founders very difficult. Last year I really tried to meet eligible candidates (ie on barcamps), but even though I met a few capable people whom I also liked, finding common ideas and visions was too unlikely in the end. Of course, I myself am no exception, I would also prefer to work on my own ideas. I try to be open for other ideas, but still.


But _why_ are hackers arrogant, and how does one differentiate between "bad" arrogance (what you described) and "good" arrogance (like Steve Jobs)?

I don't have the answer to suggest for this question now, but I hope that it starts an interesting discussion. I'll try to reply tomorrow morning.


Not all hackers are arrogant, but I think some suffer from tunnel vision.


Nonsense, everyone wants to work on their own ideas.


So finding co-founders is impossible? I think not. You can also listen to some other person's idea, recognize it as great and work on that idea.


I just thought that, all else being equal, people on both sides are equally stubborn about sticking to their own ideas. Do you find this not to be the case?


I didn't think in terms of people on sides, just about arrogant hackers. Of course there are all kinds of people who only ever consider their own ideas to be worthwhile.


If this is the case for hackers then I can at least see a very good reason for it. The _only_ reason I learned to program was for the power it gives me to create new things and explore whatever I want.

Take that away from me? Forget it, I'll do any number of occupations where I can earn more.


But some things are hard or impossible to achieve alone, so teaming up with others might be necessary.


Indeed, indeed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: