Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Two things. First, it is really troubling if Apple wants to impose a tax on transactions between app users. Tipping is used often in China (for example, in the form of "red envelopes" at Chinese New Year) and a 30% cut for Apple is simply incomprehensible and downright immoral. Second, the day that WeChat gets out of the App Store is the day that Apple becomes irrelevant in China. If the story is true, I am afraid somebody at Apple has not thought this thing through.



Apple doesn't charge for person to person transfers, or buying physical goods. They only charge if you are selling digital products (apps, features, content) through the App Store. Just those things that cost Apple to store and transfer.


Apple doesn't store and transfer any in app store purchases, nor hey store or transfer any subscription


Apple stores and transfers all of the apps that make purchases and subscriptions. Trillions upon trillions of bytes.


You must be joking.


Do you really think WeChat pays Apple for the file transfers for hundreds of millions of copies of WeChat to customer iPhones every month (when you include updates). Essentially at least 100 Megabytes times 100 to 200 million a month.


Apple has been doing diff updates for a while, meaning that the actual bandwidth consumed for updates is most likely much less than 100mb

https://developer.apple.com/library/content/qa/qa1779/_index...


Even with diffs it's a huge cost.


Yes, they pay with they developer account.

If you don't like it, please, tell Apple (or Google) that bandwidth has to be paid.

Until then, it is irrelevant if the app is 10kb or it is downloaded 12.000.000.000 times.


It's entirely relevant. That 30% pays the costs of the app store, and bandwidth is probably the biggest cost of running the app store.

Please show me where Apple says the $99 I pay every year pays for their Sales, Marketing, Distribution and Operating costs of running the app store and getting me customers.


Please, show me were the bandwith has to be paid. Until then, it is irrelevant if an app is 1kb or 1gb


You really believe someone is going to host a store for free where you get to distribute as many copies of whatever you want?

I guarantee bandwidth has to be paid for. If Apple doesn't write that check the App store ceases to exist.




Consider applying for YC's first-ever Fall batch! Applications are open till Aug 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: