Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> in Ukrainian history we almost never lost by being defeated

Nice to see Ukrainians reinventing German Stab-in-the-back mythology from interwar period.




As in all things, Greeks invented this first. Remember Efialtes, the guy who betrayed the Spartans in Thermopylae?

(In modern days also, all my friends who like football, their teams never lose a match. It's always the referee who is on the side of the other team).


It's a very powerful hammer in our psychological toolkit, and it's been used countless times throughout history.

No one wants to blame the Everyman and his masculine valor for failing the country. So the parts of the national leadership who started the war need to deflect blame, and they do it by attaching themselves to martial myths and posing as defenders of the Everyman. Not like those other dastardly effete leaders who oppose war, who are in a rhetorically weaker position because they're correctly acknowledging that individual valor doesn't play a major role in the outcome of the war. They're easily portrayed as trivializing valor and not glamorizing it sufficiently.

If you talk to old white American soldiers, you can hear the same thing about Vietnam (damn liberals!) and more recently Iraq (damn liberals!). I'm sure you could hear similar things from old Brits nostalgic for Empire.


It's much more complex than that.


After making such a statement it would be proper to elaborate on what you meant there. Don't get me wrong, I am not yearning for a debate on Ukrainian historiography here, I just believe that borderline chauvinistic statements like that should be checked.


I get your point. It would be chauvinistic if I said that we are so strong that we can't be taken by force (which is impossible), while actually I'm just saying that we are too corrupt (so that every time a pivotal point comes, someone gets bribed and betrays). And also, I'm speaking of the last 300 years, and not really the _entire_ history.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: