Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> You can write a system in any language right? Python is a scripting language and lots of people use it everyday to write systems.

Systems here means things like an operating system, a device driver, video games or a web browser, things that need fast execution, direct access to hardware and the ability to manually maintain memory. Stuff that C/C++ are normally used for.

Could you do it in Python? Not really, since Python has garbage collection, a very high-level of abstraction and is extremely slow for these kinds of tasks.

> What problems is it trying to solve?

It's trying to make it possible to write programs that require manual memory management, but that are checked for correctness of that manual memory management automatically, so that you can avoid many bugs that are related to memory and are commonplace in programs written in C/C++, like referring to a certain object that is in fact no longer present etc.

> Also how does it compare to Go? It seems to me that both Go and Rust are mainly used by C/C++ folks that want a new shiny language that somehow resemble the syntax or structure or funcionality of the former and at the same time add some modern features

Go is not really used by C/C++ programmers, as it does have a garbage collector, just like Python. Unlike Python however it is way faster and unlike Java, it is compiled to a native executable, thus it is used by many Python/Ruby/Java programmers who want a faster/native language with similar capabilities.

Go is mainly used for writing web applications and command line apps, just like Python.

> Do you feel more productive writing software in it than in let's say JS?

Rust targets a very different market from JS, but it has a very strong type system and catches a lot of errors at compile time, which to me makes it a lot more productive than JS is, just by not having things explode on me at runtime.

As for the syntax, it actually feels very neutral once you spend a couple of days with it and read the book + apart from the 'lifetime annotation there aren't really any other weird symbols for the category of language Rust is.

For example things like https://github.com/redox-os/redox or https://github.com/servo/servo would be very hard to write in both Python & Go, because they require direct access to hardware, fastest possible execution and manual memory management. They could've been written in C/C++, but would then contain many memory management errors, (given its manually done by the programmer and programmers are fallible humans), which could lead to crashes or serious security problems. Rust aims to prevent these drawbacks of C/C++, while still maintaining all of their benefits, i.e. speed, manual memory management etc.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: