Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I disagree.

Prohibition transforms capital spent by drug users into income for drug cartels. Under full legalization, drug users would have as little incentive to buy their drugs from street vendors as alcoholics would want to buy their liquor from some guy standing on a street corner.

The great news is that we are entirely responsible for this mess ourselves, so we can fix it if we want to.




The problem with full legalization is that you are making it easy for people to get the route to drug addiction.

Maybe legalization for only people who are proven addicts, but are probably the bulk of the cartel revenue would give a more favorable result ?


Why do you consider that full legalization is making it easy for people to get the route to drug addiction?

In general, lack of availability is not a strong limiting factor even in countries with full criminalization; illegal drugs can be bought by anyone willing, there exists a market in any population center.

On the other hand, drugs being available in a controlled environment makes it easier to recover from addiction, and also limits the proliferation of various highly addictive chemicals which wouldn't be preferred or used by anyone if e.g. simpler opiates were available.

Saying that full legalization will cause a huge increase in drug addiction sounds plausible, but what evidence we have (e.g. Portugal decriminalization) shows that it doesn't really cause any disaster.


> The problem with full legalization is that you are making it easy for people to get the route to drug addiction.

That's already an acceptable risk with cigarettes and alcohol, and marijuana in some places, why should it not be acceptable for everything else?


You disagree that...

1. We have the option as a consumer of not buying illegal drugs?

2. Cartels have the option of not doing horrific things?




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: