Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Some countries use cluster munition for some of their strikes. The usa last did this in 2009. The opposite of precise...



Especially when they used to also drop food aid in packages that were the same colour as the cluster bomblets.

(mostly text, but with graphic image of child with amputated limbs) http://www.rawa.org/cluster2.htm

http://www.landmineclearance.org/page2.html


Cluster munitions are bad, but you have to consider that people often try to hide in houses, in cellars during air raids in the city. Cluster munition will not do much to those people, other than being insanely noisy and terrifying. What will kill those people is a bomb that will drop the house on them.

Indiscriminate killing is a function of decision making process, not the munition itself.


Cluster munitions such as BL755 ( extensively used in Yemen at present ) were designed in the 1970s to attack massed Warpac tank formations pouring across the German plains.

As a consequence they usually contain a high proportion of shaped-charge bomblets which can quite easily penetrate several inches of concrete. Brick and roof tiles don't stand a chance. Even the shrapnel from the fragmenting jacket can penetrate steel plate.


> Cluster munition will not do much to those people,

Not all of the bomblets explode, so when those people come out of their houses they've got to not disturb any of the bomblets.


I understand that. People try to collect the bomblets afterwards though, especially in the city. So the harm is somewhat limited.


The munition can't be removed from the chain, it's not a benign entity. From concept through design and production through to sale and use, the munition itself is a necessary element in the machinery of killing.

Downplaying the importance of the munition itself enables industrialised slaughter. The arms trade deals in munitions, and is a multi-billion dollar industry.

We can prevaricate all day about words like "defense", about how "guns don't kill people, people kill people", and about suggestions that "insanely terrifying" experiences "will not do much" to people. But language is important here, and you should consider carefully what you think and communicate about the weapons industry.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: