Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

We've had the bank discussion here before, and some of it seems to come down to the fact that banks are required to do a lot of regulatory stuff that is not 'simple'.



I'm really curious about this banksimple and I hope they have really cool "grave old guys in suits" with them. They'll need it.

previous discusion at: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1049961

My previous comment in that discussion:

I work for a bank (not from USA though) and what I see as the toughest barrier in initiating a Bank is the massive amount of banking regulation that every institution must comply (not negotiable). Also the impact of new regulations on the systems running the business are usually non trivial. Missing any of these, means that you cant operate (or you can't do certain operations, generally critical).

As I said, the effort put in keeping with all this is very big. Usually the split is 50/50 with regulation vs new features (my view is as a software developer). The bank being global only makes things worse, as only adds more regulations from different places to equation.

Well that was the boring part. I think theres a place for new financial services but perhaps the way to get started is providing those new services and avoiding being a bank. As the institution adds more services and grows, it can begin to take into account the regulation little by little. That was my simplistic view ;)


There are regulatory challenges, but the other two BankSimple guys (the real brains) have figured out a ton. I'm confident we can do some cool stuff.


Best of luck then, I don't think anyone's not rooting for you here.


Link to previous discussion?

I'd be curious if incorporating outside the U.S. is the best option for them here to avoid the regulation. Or going on a SeaStead :) They'd still need relationships with Visa and Mastercard though.


Also, I'd be interested in a bank which didn't use the fractional reserve system, and did something more like the process described at the end of this video: http://www.youtube.com/user/khanacademy#p/p/CECDA315A8848B99...

It may then be tough to compete with existing banks whose insurance is subsidized by the gov though.


startups like WePay seem to be overcoming this.


WePay gets around it by partnering with an actual bank. Not the same thing as being a bank.


Reading between the lines of the banksimple website, I wonder if they are going the same route.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: