Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> You can even charge your MBP and phone together from one of those generic portable USB-C backup batteries

That is kind of cool -- but how many batteries is it going to take, in practice, to juice up a MBP from empty?




The macs battery is about 50 or so watt hours, your average $40 external battery is around 70. Disregarding inefficiencies of charging a battery from a battery, about one.

Realistically, closer to two.

To do your own math, it's mAh * voltage / 1000


> To do your own math, it's mAh * voltage / 1000

The 1 / 1000 is a millisecond? Otherwise the units work out to power and not potential energy?


1000 mAh * 1 V / 1000 = 1 Ah * 1 V = 1 Wh

Wh is energy, dividing through time would be power.


The largest Mi power bank is 16000+ mAh, smallest is 5000. MPB is 6000, phone is about 3500. So you could get about 1 or 2 charges depending on battery size of course.


You're looking at the wrong numbers. What are the watt hours?


See my reply to a sibling comment [1]. A 16,000 mAh power bank is about 75% the capacity of the 15" MBP battery.


I don't know the specs of the new MBPs, but my mid-2015 MBP's battery is 7530 mAh at full charge. You can get portable charger batteries that are much more than that these days; this one [1] is 26,800 mAh, which in theory could charge my MBP 3.5 times. In practice, less than that, but still probably at least two full charges.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Portable-Charger-RAVPower-26800mAh-Re...


You can't directly compare mAh values, as they're an unit of electric charge. The amount of energy depends on voltage, too. Power bank manufacturers are basically running a marketing scam; the batteries they sell have 3.7V while USB uses 5V. What's more, the MBP battery voltage is something around 12V.

So the 26,800 mAh power bank has a capacity of 26,800 mAh * 3.7V = 99,600 mWh = 99.6 Wh of energy. Meanwhile, the 15" MBP has a 76 Wh battery. So theoretically you can do about 1.3 charges; realistically I'd say one full charge.


A Macbook Pro (or indeed any laptop) battery operates at a voltage much higher than that of your phone or a powerbank. The actual power available from the battery (in Wh) can therefore only be compared with another battery's quoted capacity if the voltage is taken into account.

A MBP battery might be a 11.1V battery, while a portable power bank capacity is almost certainly quoted as a summation of the capacities of the 3.7V cells inside. The capacity of the power bank must therefore be divided by 3 to give the equivalent capacity in mAh at 11.1V.


That's not how electricity works.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: