Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
The Wrong Man (theatlantic.com)
72 points by danh on April 21, 2010 | hide | past | favorite | 11 comments



And as pointed out here:

http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/04/21...

... the evidence against the newer suspect Bruce Ivins (which actually did result in suicide), is similarly circumstantial but the government is dead set against anyone questioning that suspicion.


Maybe, but the circumstantial evidence against Ivins is far more damning that anything they had on Hatfill.

> Ivins had been the sole custodian of a large flask of highly purified anthrax spores genetically linked to those found in the letters. He had allegedly submitted purposely misleading lab data to the FBI in an attempt to hide the fact that the strain of anthrax used in the attacks was a genetic match with the anthrax in his possession.


Who did the genetic matching? The same FBI labs that were well known for making up results to support their cases?


Every time I start to think that our country might be on a trajectory towards improvement, a story like this comes along to throw that out the window.

It really astounds me that Dr. Hatfill managed to put up with the abuse for so long without doing anything irrational - just reading about it makes me understand why someone would want to mail anthrax to the government. Imagine how many innocent people might have been subjected to similar treatment without our knowledge, simply because - like Dr. Ivins - they didn't manage to survive?


And what about the press, who did nothing like their supposed role of objective observers, but simply served as a propaganda, shame and social torture machine. Truly disgraceful.


Why didn't he move? First thing I would have done is skipped town to Japan or something, & maybe come back after a decade.


For the same reason he didn't suicide: he knew he hadn't done it, and he wasn't going to give those lazy, dumb sons of bitches the satisfaction.


His loss then, 10 years of torture, basically. You don't play around with people that powerful.


  You don't play around with people that powerful.
He did get approximately $6 million in a settlement with the DOJ. Sounds like an explicit exoneration and a humiliating defeat for his transgressors, to me.


Ok, but how many people never get the settlement? And it's not like any of the people in power learned anything. That's tax money.


I have trouble feeling bad for someone who works with biological weapons.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: