Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> For example - suppose you worked at Nuance, and helped develop their new AI/Neural Network speech recognition system. Everything you know about Speech + AI you learned from them, in that language specific setting.

And the knowledge and experience you got from your previous job before Nuance ? where does it come from ? why would the buck stop at Nuance ? or the former company ? or the company before it ? your point is ridiculous. The knowledge I acquire, if it doesn't involve a company's secret is my own and no company owns it. There is no such thing as intellectual slavery which you basically promote. If you don't pay me I owe nothing more than the respect of your patents and other corporate secrets and those are covered by NDA.




Actually, that's a very interesting question - your prior knowledge in a field, particularly if you've paid for your education, might become significantly more valuable if a non-compete is implemented. Valuable enough perhaps to refuse Nuance the right to use your work.

Of course, the counter-argument there is that they paid you for your work, and that's why it's their property. It may follow that if the work is theirs and you can't use it, then surely your student loan in its entirety would also be their responsibility for just that reason.

Shame I have more important problems to solve in the meantime, that idea could be quite fascinating to work through.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: