Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Do you have any counter anecdote to the assertion?

Because nobody will make a study to verify that the sky is blue if there isn't at a minimum some dissenting opinion.




If increased police presence works to deter violent crime, why wouldn't it work to deter white-collar crime likewise?


Because it's not really detectable by patrolling without in-depth investigation. A patrol cop staring at e.g. a stockbroker doing insider trading would not deter it because that wouldn't be visible even as he would be doing the trades. A patrol cop sitting in all Madoff's meetings and sales presentations wouldn't prevent the Madoff scam from succeeding. There's nothing to suggest even getting a warrant without analysis of the actual trade data/accounting information/etc, which cannot really be done by most nonspecialized police officers.


It doesn't deter violent crime, it deters street crime, some of which is violent.

How much white-collar crime occurs on the street? Even violent crime off the street won't be helped much by street patrols.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: