Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Effectively, what we need to do is to get some kind of space resource rush going. Similar to what fueled the likes of the East India Company.



Yes, if only Mars were already settled and we could exploit the people there.

The question has always been what resource, with 3He and platinum being the two main contenders.

Otherwise, it could be like coal mining in Antarctica, or manganese module mining from the deep seafloor - technically possible, but not profitable, and certainly not enough for a new EIC.


> what resource

Ideas. That crazy nuclear experiment you want to run? Fat chance in Montana. But on the far side of Mars? Why not.


Why would that interest a potential East India Company-like organization?

The best I could come up with would if be it leads to a fuel production source, like the satellite at the end of Heinlein's "Blowups Happen". But we know of no such thing, nor do the economics seem to work out.


There is no "far side" of Mars. It's not tidally locked, to either the Sun or Earth.


"Far side" relative to Mars's principal human installations, not to the Earth.


You still haven't addressed why there are "principal human installations" on Mars in the first place, much less why they are only on one side of the planet, or why the experiments require local human involvement.


In space, if you have a rock, you're among the ... well, let's see.

There's about 1,000 atoms per cm^3 of interplanetary space. Let's say you've got 1 kg of silicate rock -- SiO4. That's 4 parts oxygen (atomic weight 16) to 1 part silicon (atomic weight 14).

A kilogram is about 10^30 atomic masses. So we need 10^27 cubic centimeters, which works out to about 100 million km^3.

The Earth has a volume about 16,000 times larger -- which means at the average density of interstellar space, there would be about 16,000 of those rocks you have in hand, or 16 tonnes of matter. Rather than the six thousand billion billion tonnes of matter actually in the Earth.

We've met the space resource rush and it is us.


You mean a private company that can legally declare interplanetary war?


And create addicts of the most advanced and ancient civilisation on the planet.


Or just tell the government there's oil on Titan. ;)


There's lots of liquified natural gas on the surface of Titan.


Close enough, wouldn't you say? There are slightly heavier molecules to be found there as well.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: