Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Should we, as software developers and IT professionals, be able to lobby about information security? Net neutrality?

If we can't, and Verizon/Cox also can't (they also have a conflict), who is left? People who either don't care or lack enough knowledge of the issue to make reasonable policy recommendations?




Will you directly profit if someone goes to jail as a result of the laws you're lobbying for? That is the only scenario I am talking about here.


As a developer not in the Windows ecosystem, I would have definitely benefited from lobbying on behalf of an anti-trust action against Microsoft.


Did Microsoft go to jail?


Being incarcerated is not the only nor the worst affliction that a government can bring down upon you.


Ask someone that has been in prison for a while what their opinion on this is. I think they'd disagree.


Ask someone whose loved ones have been fatally poisoned due to government negligence in rubber-stamping an environmental impact report and I think they'd offer a feisty debate.

(Or anyone at the receiving end of military action, for that matter)

The point is that drawing a line between lobbying that affects prisons (nevermind a distinction between federal, local, and other institutions of incarceration) and lobbying that affects anything else can be a largely arbitrary affair.


I have no idea what happened to your loved ones or if they have been "fatally poisoned," and if so, who was responsible for that. What I do know, based on what you said, is that the government didn't forcibly lock them in a box for X years at gunpoint. They apparently failed to publish some kind of report you wanted them to publish. Not exactly the same thing.

Criminal laws are by far the most invasive laws we have on the books, and because of that they deserve special protections against those that would seek to exploit them.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: