Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> much of Reddit's problems with its userbase boil down to a failure to manage.

Removed some words to make this statement more accurate.

Reddit itself doesn't manage the communities, and that's a problem because the Thought Police are now doing it for them.

The idea that people should be allowed to create and manage their own communities is nice in theory, but why should Xx_JoeSchmoe123_xX be in control of the largest League of Legends community? Just because he hit the 'Create Subreddit' button before anyone else? That makes no sense, but it's how all of Reddit is run.

Reddit probably thinks "This is great! We've got all these community managers (moderators) working for us and we don't even have to pay them!" But the quality of their moderation is often proportionate to their salary...




> Reddit itself doesn't manage the communities...

That used to be true. But they've been stepping in and trying to clean up speech they don't like. As soon as you take on the responsibility of cleaning up one group, you take on the responsibility for every group. And reddit just doesn't have the manpower to do it.


Nor do they have a consistent and rational policy to do it, which is why things aren't going very well.


It's an interesting point, I can imagine reddit being a platform for Gen Y politicians once subreddits are forced to elect their moderators.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: