On: Hiroshima (1946)

[hasenj]

I think would much rather my leaders just sign some sort of an armistice agreement rather than annihilate "enemy" civilians.

I mean there are ways to end a war without total destruction.

And the logic of killing civilians to save soldiers is just .. no comment.

[ksou32 → hasenj]

>And the logic of killing civilians to save soldiers is just .. no comment.

Since their was totally a way to invade Japan and not harm any civilians. Since Japan totally didn't kill millions of innocent Chinese , Vietnamese, and Philippinos. It's not a bad guy good guy comic When exactly was the last no civilian casualties war ?

We firebombed Dresden too, but you don't see Germany getting a peace day.

And remember Truman's first duty is to save the lives of the drafted men on the front lines.

[hugh4 → hasenj]

>I think would much rather my leaders just sign some sort of an armistice agreement rather than annihilate "enemy" civilians.

Great idea! Now, how do we persuade the other side to sign that agreement?

[lujim → hugh4]

Since we have our pens out we should also sign something outlawing poverty, disease, and Mondays.

[bluejekyll → hugh4]

You're making the assumption that you -need- the other side to sign an agreement. Japan was completely contained by the US at this point in the war.

This was a decision to hasten the end of the war, but did we ever actually leave? We still have bases in Japan. This was about hastening an end with a guarantee that the US would have full control of Japan.

Please don't misunderstand me though, Japan needed to be defeated thoroughly, it had acted and performed gross injustices against many people in the world. But these bombs were not necessary.

[lujim → bluejekyll]

So maybe just a tug o' war or a water balloon fight to decide the winner of the Pacific War?

We could have used those 1 million Purple Hearts we produced for the invasion of Japan for anyone who stubbed a toe during all the festivities.

[bluejekyll → lujim]

Read Howard Zinn's, 'A People's History of the United States', then get back to me.

[lujim → bluejekyll]

I will check out a summary and if it looks good I will give it a read. My googling makes it look a bit revisionist but I will check it out. Since we are starting a book club try 'With the Old Breed' by Eugene Sledge and/or 'Flyboys' by James Bradley to see the hell on earth the Japanese military had exported all over the Pacific. I was actually somewhat mentally exhausted by the end of 'With the Old Breed' and was glad when it was over. The book described something horrifying and grueling with no end in sight so I can't imagine how it would feel to actually have lived it.

[bluejekyll → lujim]

James Clavell's fictional account based on his experiences in a Japanese prison camp is wonderful read too, 'King Rat'.

I talked with my grandfather often about his service as a submariner in the pacific, brutal, but oddly he never hated the Japanese. He saved that for the French.

[lujim → hasenj]

Well to be fair soldiers are humans and aren't just completely disposable. Read "With the Old Breed" by Eugene Sledge to see the fun and games a 19 year old kid from Mobile Alabama got to have as a US Marine in the Pacific. Spoiler alert, his experience was probably about as bad as anything a human could endure.