Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Japan has 30 million more people then the UK - while having much lower agricultural land.

It it one of the most dense countries in the world. Same with Singapore and South Korea.

Why does Germany still have that trait while Britain still doesn't ?

You are talking as if society stops needing engineers after a point ?




the UK has 65 million people and Japan 120, so there is quite a big difference. Many places in Europe are also densely populated, more so than Japan even like Belgium and Netherlands.

I didn't mean to imply that engineers are not needed. But rather that I don't think the reverence for engineering is linked directly to population density and scale of a country.

Germany is a good counter example since you bring it up. The strong position of engineering in Germany vs Britain as nothing to do with population size issues but rather to historical context. Each country has very different traditions and histories.

For Germany e.g. it could be mentioned that the medieval guilds lasted far into relative modern times. They preserved the status of crafts. Other factors is that in Britain finance and trade came to dominate due to the huge colonial empire, something Germany didn't have and instead had to rely on domestic production to build their nation.

One could go on for any time about all the myriads of different experiences and traditions.

It surprises me how often people just quickly explains any sort of issue with population size. Frequently differences between Europe and the US is also explained away as a function of population size, as if the vastly different historical developments isn't of significant importance.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: