Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I bought my father-in-law a new laptop, wiped it and installed it with just what said he needed.

Only to watch him say "I want to get vlc," type vlc into Google, skip over the VideoLAN - downloads link, and click some virus-infested link further down because the title of the link was "Get vlc."




"What's VideoLAN?" ~ The not technically-focused.

This is why the scams work.


The top result for me is:

VideoLAN - Official page for VLC media player, the Open ...

The other results are all either directly or almost directly associated with VLC. I get no scam sites in the top 10 results. Have the search results improved? Is this the effect of search personalization? What gives?


That was the top result for him, but the problem was it didn't say "VLC" right up front. I believe he grabbed what looks to be the 12th link when I use a private browser, but who knows what search personalization he'd picked up along the way, since he had logged into Google. I know it was at least half-way down.


5th word in the title doesn't count as "right up front"? sigh...


Never underestimate the laziness of the human mind scanning for something. Now, I do think the text back then (1.5 years ago) might have said "VideoLAN - downloads" and that was all -- which is worse -- but I recall seeing "VLC" obviously in the description under the link, and it could have been in the link title.


Oh, well, then I understand. I wouldn't expect someone to actually read the description. Even I wouldn't underestimate laziness by that much :) I'm glad the VLC folks learned their lesson.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: