Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Best Connected Individuals Are Not the Most Influential in Social Networks (technologyreview.com)
17 points by waterlesscloud on Feb 3, 2010 | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments



For everyone like me who didn't understand the difference between an individual in a high k-shell and a hub: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K-core clarifies it nicely. (it didn't help for searching that core and shell got interchanged :))

That is, you can be a hub in a low k-shell, if say, you live in a town where everyone knows everyone but only the mailman ever leaves town.

Edit: in other words, this says that it's not about how many people you know, but how many highly-connected people you know. That's exactly what is usually informally meant by "well-connected".


See also this HN submission for the original article: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1097567

Figure 1d in the linked-to paper illustrates the difference between high k-shell and high k nicely.

To quote from the paper (where k = # of edges a node has): "We start by removing all nodes with degree k = 1. After removing all the nodes with k = 1, some nodes may be left with one link, so we continue pruning the system iteratively until there is no node left with k = 1 in the network. The removed nodes, along with the corresponding links, form a k-shell with index kS = 1. In a similar fashion, we iteratively remove the next k-shell, kS = 2, and continue removing higher k-shells until all nodes are removed. As a result, each node is associated with a unique kS index, and the network can be viewed as the union of all k-shells."


Facebook and other large online networks should make an app with such interesting profile & network analysis data. Since it is available only to individuals they won't be letting too much out anyway they are still the gold mine of the data.


> It's easy to imagine that because the links that form between various individuals in a society are not governed by any overarching rules, they must have a random structure.

I don't find that easy to imagine at all. Social systems are full of rules.


how does this k-shell metric compare to, for example, pagerank?


Best connected in social networks: Anonymous




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: