Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm not suggesting taking money from "evil" corporations... only in that money made in a locality should be taxed in that locality... getting rid of corporate 'income' taxes in favor of tariffs/vat and money exports would allow for that, with less opportunity for subverting the system, so to speak... At the end of the year, a tax refund could be given if you're a person, and transferred less than 100k out of the country.

It could be a much simpler system, with less bureaucracy needed. There are other possibilities as well. Right now, many corporations are holding onto funds, which doesn't help any economy, and worse, shifting those funds to holding companies to avoid taxes... What I'm suggesting would punish holding onto assets and encourage activity domestically... foreign goods will always be needed, and as such taxes would apply. VAT systems happen in lots of countries.




What makes you think that taxes aren't already being paid in the foreign jurisdictions?

This is a big part of the disconnect: if you (say, as Apple) sell a phone in Munich, you're paying the VAT tax in that country already.

Generally speaking, when you take the profits from your German sales back to the USA, in many (most, save a few exception) cases, you're going to pay corporate taxes on those profits now that they are repatriated back in the USA. So companies are incentivized to keep those profits in overseas jurisdictions to defer the US tax and reinvest in their overseas operations. Considering how much of their actual sales come from overseas, it's no wonder that they pursue this strategy.

EVEN IF a company wanted to be a "good US corporate citizen" and pay more taxes to the government, they'd be at a financial disadvantage to overseas companies doing business in the USA because THOSE companies DON'T have to pay tax on their overseas profits. That's why you see all of these companies set up in "corporate tax havens" that don't tax a single penny of offshore income. For one thing: it's damn easy to do international business through these companies because you effectively have a neutral ground from the perspective of finance. For another: you save money on taxes, allowing you to offer better terms to your customers and partners.

This kind of stuff only matters to the biggest corporations with multinational operations because the regulatory minefield associated with keeping track of laws and regs in lots of different countries is a nightmare and only a few top accounting firms have the talent to master it. Another reason why the law of unintended consequences shifts the tax burden to the little guy: he's not big enough to care about shifting his income overseas. When you create incentives by way of regulatory/tax arbitrage, you make it worth the while of a big multinational to invest the time and effort structure their deals so they take place in offshore jurisdictions.


This isn't money earned over seas, it's money earned in the U.S. then shifted overseas... Results from a few simple searches. Yes, it does only matter to the largest corporations, and investment firms which account for a huge percentage of wealth that further stretches an imbalance in property/wealth where fewer than 100 people have more than half the world's population combined.

I'm all for being able to make insane amounts of money, but there are limits to what is good for greater society and having underutilized holdings overseas for the simple purpose of tax avoidance isn't good for anyone. The money isn't being invested to earn more, and it isn't being spent to improve the economy. It's wasted in a corporate setting.. it should be re-invested, spent or dispersed to the share holders, who should then pay income taxes (baring a VAT/tariff system in place to replace it)

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/21/business/apple-avoided-bil...

http://motherboard.vice.com/read/apple-avoids-60-billion-in-...

http://arstechnica.com/business/2015/10/apple-google-microso...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: