Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

There is nothing to love about DST. It just messes up sleep cycle and daily routine. When you will have small children you will understand.



The flip side is having an extra hour of daylight in the evening to be able to go outside and play catch/whatever with your children.


There's no "extra" hour of daylight. The sun doesn't care how we set our clocks.


If I get home at 7 and it's dark then it doesn't really lend itself to going outside.

In daylight savings I still get home at 7 but now there is an hour of daylight left.

So even though there is still the same amount of daylight in the day, due to the rescheduling of the work day with respect to daylight, there is an extra hour of daylight in the evening


Wouldn't it be easier to redefine office hours so that people can go home at 6, instead of redefining everyone's concept of time?


Nowadays I work for myself, so yes it is easier to redefine my office hours. Changing the office/school hours of all my friends/family/children however is not feasible.

It really is an all-or-nothing sort of proposition. Can you imagine for example if half the businesses in an area ran on 9-5 and the other half ran on 8-4? You would get far more chaos than the minimal disruption caused by DST.

Now you might argue that society shouldn't be run based on the whims of people who want daylight in the evening, and you'd have a fair point. The counter to that is that likewise it shouldn't be run based on the whims of people who don't.

Luckily I live in a democracy and if, based on the will of the people, the state government where I lived decided to rescind DST then so be it and while I wouldn't like it, I would accept it.

However, I would wager that the majority of people where I live prefer daylight savings and so having it is the will of the people.


Read before you reply. Imron says "in the evening" :-S


If "the evening" refers to the period when the sun sets, then DST doesn't change anything. You still have so much daylight, no matter how you set your clock.


OTOH, if your kids wake up with the sun, DST is awesome. It means that they wake up slightly less insanely early in the summer time, and makes it slightly easier to wake them up for school at a reasonable time in the winter.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: