Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The existence of absurd EPA regulations is not a surprise. However the claim that a car can be converted to CNG for "a few hundred dollars in parts and labor" is unbelievable. You can't just throw a couple of barbeque grill tanks in the trunk. A DOT-approved CNG tank will be roughly $2000 - $3000 all by itself, based on prices at http://www.cngconversionsonline.com/

Add in other parts and labor and I'd ballpark it at around $5,000 minimum. And it has to be done properly: you don't want a CNG leak in your garage overnight. Some sort of certification of installers is warranted.




Factory(OEM) fitted LNG/CNG cars are sold in India for less than $1000 premium over gasoline versions.

Most of the non-factory fitted,quality certified, govt-regulated, certified mechanic installed gas kits cost in the same ball park range.

$5,000 is the price of a entry level Suzuki van with a factory fitted LPG kit ;).


It costs "a few hundred dollars in parts and labor" in Moscow, Russia ($400 [Lada] - $1500 [Chevrolet Suburban], Russian, Polish, and Italian parts), based on price lists on the web. Labor is cheaper here, but it takes from 4 (most cases) to 12 (non-standard cases) hours to install.


You're also probably ok without an EPA license in Russia or India. The complaint's probably valid in the context where it matters. But either way--taxing 300% or 3,000%--that's a travesty for an organization that's purportedly dedicated to preserving the environment.


New vehicles in India have to confirm to a Euro IV emission standards (equivalent).

GM sells an LPG version of a small city car in India [1]. Just so that you understand the level of market awareness and "capitalism" in play.

[1] http://indianautosblog.com/2009/06/chevrolet-spark-lpg-launc...


In India, a hack conversion (not approved by government) costs about $200 in parts + labor (not including the tank). And yes they use a domestic gas tank (similar to barbeque grill tank) kept in the trunk.


It's important to note that LPG (liquefied petroleum gas, mostly propane) is very much not the same thing as CNG (compressed natural gas) from an engineering perspective.

CNG tanks have to keep much higher pressures and are therefore quite a bit more expensive. As a previous commenter noted, $2k-$3k just for the tank is about right, at least for a new, light unit. If you're willing to go the solid steel route, you can probably still get something old and heavy [1] for under $1k, but good luck finding capacity at under $100/GGE (gasoline gallon equivalent).

Lastly, there's the safety question. Currently, CNG cars have remarkably good real-world crash experience. I don't believe there's a single tank burst or fire in a collision [2]. I'd be curious to know if other countries, with more lax regulations, have as good safety statistics.

TANSTAAFL

LNG (liquefied natural gas) is also quite different from LPG. I've looked into it, if only as an emergency reserve fuel tank. Turns out that to store it indefinitely requires refrigeration (or, presumably, absurd amounts of insulation), else it'll boil off, escaping out the pressure relief valve installed in the tank for just such an eventuality. Fortunately, like a pot of water on a stove, it doesn't all boil off at once, so there's little risk of leakage if one always uses enough vapor to keep the pressure down.

[1] To the tune of hundreds of pounds. This is less likely to be a concern for converting trucks, but I notice a fuel economy difference carrying just one adult passenger in my Civic GX. [2] I haven't looked this up in the last 3 years or so. Corrections/updates are appreciated.

Edit: added paragraph on LNG.


http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/%5Ccng-conversio...

CNG conversion kits costs about Rs 20000 (approx $400) according to the above article


That's for autorickshaws, which are closer to a motorcycle than an automobile.

The fuel economy quoted in the article (40km/kg) is around twice that of my Civic GX (30mile/GGE=30mile/5.660lb=30mile/2.567kg=51.5km/2.567kg=20km/kg), which is consistent with motorcycle numbers.

They also quote an autorickshaw traveling around 100km per day. Since the Civic with an 8GGE tank has a 400km range, the autorickshaw tank would need to be 1/16th the size. Assuming tank costs are linear and a new 8GGE tank is $3k, that puts the rickshaw tank at under $190.

I suspect the non-tank portion will also scale at least linearly with number of cylinders. Assuming a single-cyclinder motorcycle engine and 4 cylinder car, that runs the price up to $4k total, which, unsurprisingly, is still cheaper than here in the US but not by $10k.


However much the parts and labor costs the licensing fee adds $10k which is very significant.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: