I'm still not understanding where your criticism is directed. GNFS (see? no typo this time. Do I get a cookie?) is quite clearly outside of PTIME, though I'm not sure to which definitions of SUBEXP and EXPTIME it belongs. Thus RSA remains an algorithm which is infeasible for tractable key sizes, even if the early guesses of 512-1024 bits turned out to be wrong.
Polynomial time: O(n^c)
GNFS time: O(c^(n^(1/3))
Exponential time: O(c^n)