Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> I lost heart quickly because I could find no tools that were interactive, simulating and stimulating to use, preferably visual like this.

This is because there is no use-case for professional users.

When it comes to computational chemistry there are two possibilities:

The computational load is low, but also accuracy like the implemented force-field method. Now you can calculate molecular properties so fast that it feels interactive.

Or you use more accurate methods (hybrid density functionals). For decently sized molecules (>100 atoms) you now might want to consider using HPC (speak supercomputer). Now you have something which is state of the art, but it's not interactive anymore.

If you however use computationally cheap methods, you probably want to calculate properties of a LOT of molecules (high throughput calculations, screening). This means you must either use known structures, or generate them programmatically (using some genetic algorithm usually). Now you don't need anything interactive either.




You're right but this application is designed mostly for educational purposes. It's a web application so students and teachers can use their mobile device (iPad, iPhone, Android devices, etc.) to use the features this application offers. They can easily understand the stereochemistry of a molecule rather than using those modeling kits.


> This is because there is no use-case for professional users.

I don't know, it can still useful for generating your initial cells for complicated systems (defects, interfaces, etc.), and it can always be useful to test an idea qualitatively before you do a high-accuracy calculation.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: