Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | rjrogerto's comments login

As others have commented - this is unsurprising - and makes a lot of sense from a technical perspective. Don't see this as scammy at all. And as for the product - the main qualm seems to be the lack of utility vs cost - which again does not seem scammy to me.


The article says nothing about the R1 being “scammy” - only that its functionality is overlapped by devices you likely already own. Also unsurprising for a $200 device, which is only even marketed to be a novel interface. Honestly if it’s less addictive than a smartphone due to being more limited, that could be reason enough to carry one.


It’s not that it being based on android is the surprising part, it’s that they designed and sold a physical device which could be replaced with an app on the hardware you already have.

The whole device seems to be “it’s Siri but as a standalone device” and since you still have to take your phone with you, it seems to provide no value.


Nobody was going to pay $200 for that app w/ 85 gazillion LLM wrappers already out there, so they need some other form factor to get traction.


>it’s that they designed and sold a physical device which could be replaced with an app on the hardware you already have.

Smartwatches are exactly that, and some people buy those.


Smart watches do quite a lot that my phone can’t. Primarily health/fitness tracking, and being on my wrist.

This device is essentially a phone in every way but massively less functional. I can’t see a single thing it does better or more conveniently.


It can do a lot more than ChatGPT's app, let alone Siri which can do even less.


The scam is that the hardware is unnecessary, expensive, and strictly worse than just using your phone.


That doesn't make it a scam though, just a waste of money. A scam would be something like, you order it and what turns up is a photo of the device with a QR code on the back linking to a download for the app.


the line isn't that clear cut. broken promises that create a sale could certainly be construed as 'scammy'.


I don't know too much about this product - did they promise not to run it on Android?


The scam is that it uses Playwright and no LLM actually exists.


Market isn't an optimization problem. Market can decide what is necessary or isn't. I would pick this up for $200 if the models were running locally.


I think we all would. But realistically no $200 device is going to run models locally.


You can run models on anything if you try


They don’t though. And if they did, it would cost more than $200. Like, say, a phone.


Great idea, as a recent new Dad can definitely see the value of this. What is the technology you used to develop it? Flutter...?


This is so cool. What did you use for the send button animation...Rive?


Hey! It's a Flutter application, so I'm using their concept of Hero animations [1]. It renders a new component (the flight shuttle?) that does the visual animation.

[1] https://flutter.dev/docs/development/ui/animations/hero-anim...


Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: