Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | mmx4332's comments login

This may not be a popular question, but given the amount of poverty in India, is a space program really the best expenditure?

As a geek, I love the space program.

As a human, I don't think it makes sense given the poverty.


A nation isn't a singular-minded entity; rather, it comprises diverse citizens who assume various roles and contribute uniquely to global improvement. Just because they've successfully landed a rover on the moon doesn't imply the abandonment of all efforts to alleviate poverty.

Honestly, why does the recognition of India's positive accomplishments always seem overshadowed by the specter of poverty and other challenges? Did the Americans eradicate every societal issue before embarking on their lunar mission? Indians should be proud — this accomplishment is truly remarkable and signifies positive societal strides toward a better collective future. Such achievements ignite hope, and progress is fundamentally built upon hope, regardless of the symbolic origins it might stem from.


An alternative perspective to consider, what happens to all the skilled engineers interested in and capable of working on advanced technologies like those intended for space if a country decides to put all other development on hold to singlemindedly focus on eradicating poverty?

What would happen to the next generations of talented potential engineers? What value would there be to pursuing an advanced education? Since obviously a space program isn't the only "luxury" that should be put on hold if poverty exists!

The talent would all leave and the next generations would be less incentivized to pursue the very kinds of careers that help a country develop.


Look at the US military budget

https://cdn.cfr.org/sites/default/files/image/2020/12/002_mi...

versus education

https://i0.wp.com/cef.org/wp-content/uploads/slide2-1.jpg

As a human I think you should arrest Elon Musk immediately for misleading advertising and fraudulent claims.

As a human I think the US should open its borders for immigrants from Asia.

As a human I think the US should scrap the petrodollar and licence as much nuclear tech as possible.


It doesn't mean anything. Nobody can "own" something like that. And nobody "owes" anything either to anyone else.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: