Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | jonathanbgood's comments login

Yes, their birth rate assumptions would only yield the population milestones they suggest if the life expectancy was significantly below the reported level.


Thanks for pointing it out - we fixed this to 200,000 B.C.


We use the world population and average life expectancy to calculate births in a year. To connect these point estimates at the varying times in history we use a bounded exponential growth model for births.


I'm still not completely getting it. Let's say in some year there are a billion people alive and the average life expectancy is 50 years. How are these two pieces of information sufficient to determine how many children were born in that year?


You also need the previous year's population. With population and life expectancy, you can approximate the per capita death rate, and then it's a straightforward linear equation.


What about infant mortality? If a million babies are born in the year 234BC, and die before 233BC rolls around, they won't be counted in the population for either year.


That's what I'm wondering about. The infant mortality rates in pre-industrial times were astoundingly high, but I don't see anything that tries to explicitly account for them. I guess they get rolled in with life expectancy (bringing the mean way down), but it would be nice to see an explicit formula for births_t.


Last night an Egyptian in Toronto, who felt powerless to help in the midst of the bloodshed, asked if we could create a place for Egyptians and the world to remember the lives that have been lost in the protests in Egypt.


I read that this is an urban myth and actually only a few percent of the people who have ever lived are alive today.


Ever lived != lived since year 1. That said I just looked at the table on wikipedia and did some simple calculations. In any case even if more people died since year 1 than are alive today, not many more died.

If you take ALL deaths, that does greatly outnumber the people alive today.


thanks for spotting this, we fixed it


... but added a new typo :)

Everyone holds a sliver of someone’s life and the letting everyone share those slivers can create a wonderful place to vividly remember someone.

Tip: proof-read a text backwards (word-by-word) to catch things that your brain would normally gloss over.


wow! fixed that one too


Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: