Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | gdfhhgddhjj's comments login

Seems like it’s aimed at business class. Businesses certainly don’t care about externalities they don’t foot the bill for.


It’s really not clear what the electron app even provides over the same app in chrome. Its own icon, sure, but the behavior is just as bad as on the web—just take slack for example.


It offers access to file system and system resources as well as multi platform build support. Developers like all people will whine over anything. For students and indie devs who have little time, support, and resources things like electron are great


Right, but does eg slack actually use any of that? It’s not a great native client by any stretch—it doesn’t use a native UI, it’s not particularly snappy, and it doesn’t do any special integration. So, it seems that electron is mostly a way to distinguish certain sites from others, not that they provide a better experience.

Granted I do like the distinct app icon. But electron should mean more than that to qualify as meaningfully native.


What electron gives Slack is A) local install and B) proper notifications.

So Slack gets an icon on the homescreen and possibly offline notification + notification integration with the OS.

That might be pretty limited from a technical perspective, but it's a massive product thing from a product perspective.

Also, it's possible they may use file access for caching/storage etc..


Not closing and losing your data when your chrome crashes?


These are all true things about any language on earth, except perhaps the evolving part.


Well, this is true today at least. What are you surprised at?


What makes you think I am suprised?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: