On: Show HN: Mantaphrase, an app that lets you convers...

[hnriot]

As a Brit who lived in St Gallen for a couple of years, I never found any problem, the Swiss all speak perfect Swiss, English, French and German. My schoolboy French was useless because the moment I would open my mouth they would instantly switch to English, even in rural areas.

[eru → hnriot]

> the Swiss all speak perfect Swiss, English, French and German

What do you mean by perfect Swiss? (To be honest, as a German I am inclined to classify Swiss German as its own language. Especially since we already grant Dutch to be a different language from German.)

[eric_bullington → eru]

He probably means Romansh. It's one of Switzerland's national languages, although only a small minority of the population speaks it.

[eru → eric_bullington]

Yes. It's always fun to bring that up, because people generally see Switzerland as trilingual only. Haven't met a speaker of that language, yet, though.

[lignuist → eru]

I met some. It was fun to see, how they could communicate with spanish people.

[anuleczka → hnriot]

Yeah, I've found it really depends. Shortly after I came here, I had one Swiss person say in a huff (and in perfect English!), "You've been here for three months, and you still don't speak French?" How long ago did you live in St. Gallen? These days it seems like there's a bit of anti-foreigner mentality, so I've noticed I get a warmer reception if I at least try to speak the language.