The philosopher David Thorstad keeps a blog with critiques of EA and related ideas. His writing strikes me as fairly patient and in good faith. (Or at least, it's more measured than some of my own comments on this thread!)
He wrote this good dissection of the Bostrom email controversy, and why the apology doesn't cut it:
That said -- it did happen way back in the 90's. There has to be a place for forgiveness, even for imperfect people offering imperfect apologies. My sense is that there's plenty of other things to criticize that are more recent and more central to this general school of thought.
He wrote this good dissection of the Bostrom email controversy, and why the apology doesn't cut it:
https://ineffectivealtruismblog.com/2023/01/12/off-series-th...
That said -- it did happen way back in the 90's. There has to be a place for forgiveness, even for imperfect people offering imperfect apologies. My sense is that there's plenty of other things to criticize that are more recent and more central to this general school of thought.