Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You are conflating 'violent revolution' with 'communism'.

Typically ALL revolutions end badly, ala 'Robespierre'. NOT just communist revolutions.

Also typically, almost everyone in the USA, since the US had one of the very few examples of a successful revolution (geography helped), think that revolutions are a great thing, a big party, everyone should do it.

After/throughout WW1-WW2 a lot of people were oppressed, poor, and pissed enough to revolt, and during that period there were a lot of ideas we lump into 'communism'. So, this ferment of anger, seeded with the common ideas of the time, lead to a lot of communist revolutions.

But most revolutions fail, that isn't indictment of the original ideas.

At the time, even Woodrow Wilson's 14-points, would sound like Communism to todays American. In democracy, everyone gets a vote, in todays America, even that is too communist.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: