Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

He might be considered by others as "boomer" that hasn't been relevant "since Quake III"



If so, then they missed the games that used id Tech 4 and id Tech 5 (almost impossible given the success of Doom 3), and how Carmack continued to invent truly unthinkable performance and fidelity enhancements to real time 3D graphics until the day he left for Occulus.

Then at Occulus he translated that engineering talent into a ruthless attack on latency and other issues with VR at the time. He was even working on this before he left.

Anyone who has watched one of his QuakeCon Keynotes in the past 20 years knows just how much raw talent Carmack has as an engineer. Most of them are on YouTube, you should check them out.


I think this also sums up his weakness though in a megacorp like Meta. He's technically brilliant, and that can go a very long way. But in a large corporation, technical brilliance is secondary to excellence in leadership.

I remember reading an article in the '00s or '90s about how Id worked, and it just seemed not very scalable beyond Carmack.

And while he his companies have had great success, other '90s era peers - Valve and Epic - are on a whole other level today. Technical brilliance brought his company far, but it can't bring you to those heights.


The man went from making the fastest 3D games ever to grace silicon to literally launching rockets. He's been the fastest nerd alive, and Meta couldn't even give him legs (figuratively and literally [1])

[1] https://youtu.be/ouq5yyzSiAw?t=395


I don't see what you didn't do there.


How many people that ignorant actually work there though? Maybe there really is more dead weight than we thought..


Whoever those others are…they are irrelevant.


I wonder how many people don't value his opinion because (they assume) Carmack can't solve LeetCode as well as they can.


Are you sure you don't mean a "Gen-X'er" that hasn't been relevant since he stole Apple ][s with thermite and vasoline? ;)


Respect your elders


But that’s not the gen z way. Part of being young is thinking you’d somehow do it all differently in the same circumstances.


“Beware an old man in a profession where men die young”

I am in my late 20s, and I think there’s plenty to learn from the past that still applies to the world of today. When a seasoned veteran says something, I shut up and listen, because there’s often a learnable tidbit there, or at least a fun war story.


That’s an attribute of youth in general. No single generation owns it exclusively.


Which is why I said “part of being young.” That said, I don’t remember being so explicitly mad at previous generations when I grew up (as a millennial). “Ok boomer” is a big part of the gen z vocabulary.


"ok boomer" in gen z speak tends to be a jab at millenials, not something directed seriously at the legitimately wisened.


I've seen it used by both millenials and zoomers, mostly directed at boomers. It captures a general sentiment that is widespread among those generations that the boomer generation uses (or used existing) systems of power to benefit themselves to the detriment of younger generations and then complains as the younger generations struggle to earn their place in those systems.


What makes you say that? Certainly tiktok seems to be full of a lot of generational humor/videos, which must explicitly naming boomers and often showing people their age. But maybe I’m too old to understand their explicit gripes.


ok, whatever.

Uuuuuuh, John Carmack is a Gen-X'er...

How do you insult them?


Say something bad about Soundgarden. *

* Please don’t say something bad about Soundgarden.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: