Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It shows the short term advantages of adding a lane. It pays no mind to what sort of development the new, higher traffic flow will bring, and how that will eventually doom that third lane addition to be just as congested as before. The solution isn’t adding more capacity to roads, it’s getting more people and things off the roads and onto alternative means of transportation.



Make alternative means better (chiefly faster or overall cheaper) and people will adopt them. People might not all be geniuses, but they’re not stupid.


Add the externalities to the cost of transport and then you can discuss the cost


Corollary: when people can’t see the externalities, they reach decisions that logically ignore them.


You're assuming that satisfying demand is not a good. You're also arguing that we should wear a hair-shirt until the rapture. (If the alternatives can't compete with relatively good traffic, if they're only used when nothing else works, how good are they.)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: